Volunteer critics listen to an album in its entirety while discussing music and life.
Sobriety is optional.
This week: Late Registration by Kanye West
Number of critics: 4
Percentage of critics under the influence: 100
Percentage of critics that had heard of D’Angelo during last week’s review of ‘Voodoo’, which spurred this author to choose a more mainstream album: 50
Years ago that ‘Late Registration’ came out: 7.5
Minutes into discussion before we hear Bernie Mac‘s (RIP) voice on the intro: 6
Time into first song, ‘Heard ‘Em Say’, that it takes a critic to say “this sounds like Kanye!, in seconds: 5
Time after that exclamation that she asks, “Wait, is this Kanye?”, in seconds: 2
Times that this author had mentioned this was a Kanye West album: 4
Position on the Billboard charts at which this album debuted: 1
Number of worldwide sales to date, in millions: 3.5
Grammy nominations and awards garnered by this album: 8, 3
Posters of Kanye West on the wall of this author’s room, where the review is taking place: 8
Percentage of critics who have never heard of the album: 50
Percentage of these ill-informed critics who are from Kanye’s hometown of Chicago, Illinois: 50
Jaws dropped after learning of last two facts: 2
Entire verses of ‘Gold Digger‘ rapped word for word by an unexpected critic: 3
Times that the quietest critic has heard the unedited version of ‘Golddigger’: 0
Number of critics who could identify Paul Wall and GLC on ‘Drive Slow’: 0
Years since Common, featured on ‘My Way Home’, has put out anything good: 6
Words uttered by critics during ‘Crack Music‘s’ fiery spoken word outro, performed by Malik Yusef: 0
Critics deeply insulted after another critic wishes we could have been in college in 2005 so that Kanye instead of Macklemore would have come to campus: 1
Time that goes by before she pushes the issue and claims that Macklemore is one of the best rappers out right now, in minutes: 7
Position, out of 23, that a critic realizes he is on his fraternity’s pledge point leaderboard: 23, lamentably
Number of critics’ dogs named after Brandi, featured on ‘Bring Me Down’: 1
Critics who recognized the anxious, dissonant Etta James sample on ‘Addiction’: 2
Acknowledging chuckles after Jay-Z’s line, “I’m not a businessman, I’m a business, man!”: 5
Time spent discussing marketability versus talent and the emerging hip hop meritocracy, in minutes: 9
Times a new critic says “guys” after bursting into the room: 13
Number of critics who immediately question the sobriety of said critic, correctly: 3
Times said critic follows her series of “guys” with the word “listen”: 6
Time elapsed before another reviewer says more than a sentence in the midst of her important story, in minutes: 5.5
Number of kick boxing moves she demonstrates while telling said story: 4
Time after new critic’s entrance that this author realizes the focus has been lost from Kanye West’s album, in minutes: 20
Tracks left unreviewed: 4
Number of those tracks that are this author’s favorite song of all time: 1